Couch Soup logo

Did Doctor Who’s “The Giggle” Prove It’s a Fiery New Start? Madness, Puppets and Politics, the 60th Anniversary Finale

by: 
hello world!
Ben Hazell
| December 23, 2023
hello world!

Last time, I wrote an article worried that the show might be focusing its budget on specific episodes. This time, we see that it is absolutely true in the best possible way. “The Giggle” is Doctor Who at its very best and sometimes stumbling. Stinging social commentary that stumbles in places, mixed with outlandish villain antics, all topped off with insane reveals that may in fact, have implications for years to come both in the past and the future of everything Who. We are looking at must-watch TV for any Doctor Who fan here folks, and the reasons why might just be some of the most interesting writing techniques I’ve seen in a long time.


*Spoilers ahead, watch out!*

This episode begins with the return of the 1st Doctor’s enemy, “The Toymaker”, now played by Neil Patrick Harris. From the start, we see him bring some of his amazing flexibility in acting, portraying a stereotype interspersed with terrifying revelations about his disinterest in the value of human life. The next time we see him, he’s portraying a different stereotype completely. It’s really clear from the offset he is the real deal. He’s giving 100% and loving the sadistic character. His villainous leitmotif is his own giggle; he uses it to infect the minds of others to play his games, and you can hear it infect the soundtrack of this episode, almost like he’s doing it to the viewer also. It’s brilliant!

The Toymaker Dances with the Doctor in a top cat and a suit
He does French and German accents, and has outfits to match. Like Megamind once said, the most important thing for a villain is presentation!

It’s a really chilling opening, as he hands off a doll that becomes the blueprint for modern media through John Logi Baird’s experiments with the creation of television. The doll is terrifying and is actually a replica of the real doll used in these experiments. No wonder everyone’s scared of puppets if this nightmarish thing was ingrained in our viewing habits, huh? It was good to see the educational side of Who again, considering Doctor Who was created originally to teach children.

A picture of the Puppet used in the first television broadcast.
Why do they need such big noses for those puppets?

In 2023, we find that the Toymaker has utilized the doll as an infection on media screens, turning the real world into social media discourse, where everyone spills out their unfiltered thoughts and beliefs without a care in the world. Sadly, Davies doesn’t go into the wider ramifications of this, perhaps resulting in coups against dictators around the world and TV networks being forced to revive Firefly Still, we are led to believe this is a very bad thing.

This cascades into commentary on people being paranoid. A cure for a person’s brain waves being discussed as a “Conspiracy” that the public rejects and, weirdly, implies a complete lack of faith in other people. I get this is social commentary, but the writing openly seems to think that everyone would go insane when, in reality, people who think similarly would absolutely huddle up and cooperate. It tries to make a face mask or vaccine analogy but fails to understand the finer nuances of the concept, treating it like a wholly bad thing without realizing this would unite as much as divide people. Perhaps an hour-long story with multiple plots wasn’t enough time to explore this concept. Quite strange, given the meta-commentary in this episode is on point and brutally decisive.

This is my only problem with the episode. The politics seem very weak and surface level, whereas with a Science fiction show, we’re supposed to explore ideas and concepts born from political and social intrigue.

A mock show parodying conspiracy theorists on Fox News.
This doesn’t really make as much sense when you realise the behavioral changes are seen instantly, unlike vaccines but the show wants to make a point.

This is the first reason why I believe this story should have been a two-part episode, “The Wild Blue Yonder” did not need to exist when this episode could easily have been a trilogy, with “The Star Beast” as the opener and this episode split into two parts. (That would be quite funny actually, considering the Doctor splits into two in this episode).

The Doctor and Donna track the Toymaker back to The Early 20th Century, and they have an amazing back-and-forth argument while the Toymaker throws balls for the Doctor to catch. The sharp choreography implies that dropping the ball during their heated discussion could have dire consequences. Donna eventually catches the ball and doesn’t throw it back, which is really clever to me because it means he works on implicit consent for his games. Because Donna is a no-nonsense character, she’s his anti-thesis in a way.

Donna yells "Enough" at the Toymaker
I think even the Doctor is kind of scared of Donna sometimes.

The implication is that the human race’s consciousness and behavior as a whole is the contract he needs to play his games and that the Doctor is different as a renegade of his species. And Donna can stop games from continuing through sheer force of will, a great call back to the episode “Turn Left” where she similarly averted a world-ending catastrophe through her own determination. The mechanisms in place that each character works around are all perfect. Every game needs a player, and without a willing player, his existence is pointless.


I have to talk about the show’s new meme. The Toymaker comically rips apart the Doctor’s excuses for his past companions exits/deaths by yelling, “Well that’s alright then” with his puppet show whenever he argues against their deaths being tragic, laughing in the face of previous showrunner Steven Moffat, who admittedly wanted his characters to both die and not die at the same time, three times in a row. Poor Rory Williams was killed multiple times, and honestly, I wish he’d been brought up, but, as is typical of Doctor Who, companions like Mickey, Dan, Graham, Yas, Rory and Jack Harkness don’t really get mentioned all that much because they weren’t the main companions at the time. Ncuti’s Doctor even brings up Adric from Peter Davidson’s run later in the episode. Toymaker had way more material to work with but maybe he just doesn’t like Moffat.

The Doctor Who ""Well that's alright then" meme, Parodying Star Trek 2 writing issue.
Seems like this one might have become the rallying cry for bad writing decisions everywhere! Source: Ifunny

Finally, the coup de grace of the Toymakers’ performance, a deadly Spice Girls sing-a-long. I’m not joking; he lip-syncs, dances, throws characters into walls, murders two men, and the Doctor gives emotional apologies while Toymaker just can’t stop his funky dancing. With the soldier’s faces stuck in balloons he’s turned them into; it’s completely insane and amazing. Jemma Redgrave and Bonnie Langford interact with him really well during the sequence. I almost forgot to mention Langford is here playing 6th Doctor companion Mel Bush, but she doesn’t really do anything. I think she’s just here as a cameo to celebrate the anniversary. Nice to see her though!

It’s a 10/10 scene. Immensely funny.

Kate Stewart being forced to dance with the toymaker, Reference is to "A series of unfortunate events".
Wait what? Why are we dancing? Is that the guy from the depressed Netflix show?

Last time, I talked about how Tennant and Tate carried the show splendidly. Well, with Harris here, the cast has almost reached perfection for acting off each other but we can’t really go on without talking about the man of the hour.

Ncuti Gatwa makes his appearance via a new type of regeneration, and oh boy, if the episode wasn’t good enough already, this made it iconic. They call it “Bi-regeneration”, where Gatwa is literally pulled out of Tennant, leaving both Doctors alive. It’s confusing and really quite odd Davies would choose to do this right after mocking a previous showrunner for nonsensically allowing his characters to survive.

This also allows a viewer the chance to discount the timeless child reveal from season 11. With the Toymaker noting that he “made a jigsaw of the Doctor’s history”. Tennant’s Doctor would remain that Timeless child in essence, with Gatwas’ Doctor being 100% Time Lord in biology, which returns him to the status quo we were used to before that jarring plot point existed. It’s an ingenious writing ploy by the team that allows you to decide what you want the show’s lore to be.

The 15th Doctor is Pulled out of the 14th Doctor.
There was a point I was thinking they were going to have a two headed Doctor, but this works just as well!

His name is pronounced “Shoo-ti Gat-wa” for all us confused native English speakers out there, and he brings a very strong manic energy to the character. Incredibly grounded and confident. He sounds like a big brother you’d trust to take care of bullies. During the three-way, life-or-death catch game, he almost takes out David Tennant’s Doctor on accident, getting completely immersed and perhaps showing that he may have some hidden depths, perhaps some scheming tendencies? He takes control of everything as the Doctor for the rest of the episode, immediately sidelining Tennant’s incarnation believably and effectively. This is the Doctor now.

While Tennants’ new Tardis design was white like a blank canvas, Gatwas’ sports a new Jukebox with added yellow mood lighting. He gives off very chill and mellow vibes, like he always has the answer to emotions as well as technology. He seems very emotionally stable, the opposite of Tennant, Which is a welcome change. I would liken him to Christopher Eccleston‘s Doctor most of all, but time will tell with the Christmas special what kind of Doctor he truly is.

Ncuti gatwa's Doctor salutes in the Tardis with no trousers on.
He’s not wearing pants in this scene and apparently that was David Tennant’s idea, no idea why but it’s pretty funny.

Tennant’s Doctor got to settle down again, becoming part of Donna’s family. It’s hilarious how there are now so many versions of the 10th Doctor running around time and space, not to mention the possibility that one day he returns to this particular face again, after all the 50th shows that at some point Tom Baker will be re-used. It does, however, open up a possibility of Donna, her daughter Rose, and Tennants’ Doctor doing audio adventures, which would be pretty good in my opinion. The possibilities are endless.
*Spoilers end here”

This was an episode worthy of the 60th-anniversary title. While the 50th brought in Multiple Doctors and resolved a massive long-running plotline, this episode resolved a plotline almost 60 years in the making. Bringing back a villain from the past with very modern sensibilities, who is one of the best villains the show ever had. I came out of this episode praying that Neil Patrick Harris would be returning in the future. I also came out feeling like the show was in safe hands with Gatwas’ limited performance in the episode. His charm and demeanor make me feel the same as I did with Christopher Eccleston’s debut, hopeful and exhilarated. I know the show still has some issues to work through, but I’m confident it can resolve them in an inventive and respectful way to the source material.

One of the best episodes ever made of Doctor Who, if there’s nothing else I can say, it’s that.

The cast watch 15th Doctor's Tardis vanish
“Where’s he going?” “Everywhere”.
Hey fellow nerds! Before you dive back into that gaming session or start your next binge-watch, here’s the deal with Couch Soup: we’re a completely independent pop culture site run by genuine fans who get just as hyped as you do about the latest games, comics, movies, and TV shows. No corporate overlords, no AI-generated content, just real people who know their Metroid from their Mass Effect.

Unlike the big corporate sites, we don’t chase clicks or stir up drama. Sure, we might have some hot takes (looking at you, controversial season finale), but they come from a place of genuine passion and respect for the creators and fandoms we cover.

Want to support what we do and join what we think is the coolest community of pop culture enthusiasts on the internet? Check out our supporter tiers – each packed with perks that’ll level up your fandom experience. Every contribution helps keep us independent and lets us keep nerding out with you!

Thanks for being part of our quest – now, back to our regularly scheduled geekery!
Drew Lewis,
Editor-in-chief
Membership
Monthly
Yearly
Members Only Newsletter
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Ability to Comment on Articles
Unlocked
Access to Couchsoup Community
Circle Forum
SIGN UP
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Annual Membership
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Annual Membership
Annual Membership
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Annual Membership
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN
Annual Membership
Everything in free +
No Ads on the Site! Woohoo!
5% Couch Soup Store Discount
Monthly AMA chat with CouchSoup team members
Early access (up to 72hrs) to new
episodes
Access to exclusive members only
content (video & articles)
JOIN

About the Author

  • Ben Hazell

    Ben is a writer and video game enthusiast from somewhere mysterious in the North East of England. He spends a lot of his time either jamming out to music or playing video games with stories which take his fancy, or if they include fun and immersive multiplayer. As Magnasword2 on YouTube and Twitch, he's made gameplay videos and streams for the past seven years. (Oh no has it been that long already...)

Share This

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Comments are for members only. Sign up here to become a member for free.

Buffalo Puzzles Advertisement

Get our Newsletter!

Featured

The New Sonic The Hedgehog 3 Trailer Has Me Rolling Around In Excitement

The second trailer for Sonic the Hedgehog 3 has dropped, making Tom roll around in excitement. Join him as he tells you why this will be the movie of the year.
by Thomas RichardsDecember 10, 2024
1 2 3 868

Read more

Kirby and the Forgotten Land Constructs a World of Liminal Space

The Kirby franchise has always flirted with elements of horror just under the surface, but the newest entry, Kirby and the Forgotten Land, kicks that up to 11 with its eerie liminal spaces. Tyler looks at what “liminality” is and why it’s so damn important to this game!

Ahsoka Episode 4 – It’s Duel-o-Mania

Who’s ready for Duel-o-Mania, the Star Wars wrestling PPV? No? Ok, here’s the Ahsoka Episode 4: Fallen Jedi recap. Can Ahsoka and Sabine beat the clock to stop the bad guys from reaching Thrawn? Find out here!
by Iain McParlandSeptember 10, 2023 
1 2 3 265
© 2024 CouchSoup, LLC. All Rights Reserved
Terms of Service | Privacy
© 2024 CouchSoup, LLC. All Rights Reserved
Manage Cookie Settings chevron-down